Supported Browser
  • About Us
  • Subscribe
  • Contact us
Economics & Finance

Who should shoulder the cost of bank bailouts?

Shellie Karabell |

INSEAD professor of finance Theo Vermaelen makes a case for his own version of convertible capital as the panacea to government bailouts when banks fail.

Bankers and bureaucrats have been trying since the worst period of the financial crisis to figure out a way to reduce the costs to taxpayers next time banks get into trouble.

One popular suggestion making the rounds is “contingent capital”, often also called “coco bonds”. That is, bonds that convert into equity when a bank gets into trouble. This means the bond-holders will have to become shareholders and not be bailed out by the tax payers.

“Coercion” Capital

INSEAD Finance Professor Theo Vermaelen has gone one step further, creating something called a COERC (Call Option Enhanced Reverse Convertible). It’s a bond that “coerces” the equity holders to pay back the bondholders in case of financial distress. Specifically, whenever a market-based measure of leverage increases above a trigger, the bonds will convert into equity. However, the conversion price will be significantly below the stock price corresponding with the trigger. At the same time, equity holders get pre-emptive rights (options) to buy the shares at the same price as the bondholders. In order to avoid massive dilution, equity holders will exercise these options and repay the debt. As a result bondholders will lend money at very low interest rates as they know they will be repaid in case of financial distress.

Market-based triggers have been criticized because they encourage short sellers to buy the bond and short the stock, forcing economically unjustified dilution. So what’s to keep bond holders from shorting the stock, pulling the market-based trigger, and walking away with the company at bargain-basement prices?

“The great thing about the structure of the Coerc ,” Vermaelen says, “is that if you short the stock, the company will not deliver the shares to cover your short position. The shares will be purchased by the equity holders so that you have to cover by buying shares in the market, making short selling unattractive. In other words, we want to make sure that any undesirable conversion can be undone by giving shareholders the right of first refusal. This essentially means that you cannot do anything to the stockholders against their will: if we don’t want you to own the shares we have the right to pay you back and buy the shares ourselves."

What do COERCs cost?

So who buys COERCS and at what price? “It’s an instrument that should appeal to risk-averse investors,” says Vermaelen. “Banks would issue them and buyers would be risk-averse institutional investors. Indeed by setting the trigger price significantly above the conversion price, you make the bonds less risky. Because of the low risk, they are easy to value and should not have any trouble getting a credit rating.”

So far banks don’t seem very enthusiastic about the Coerc: they prefer triggers based on capital ratios, which are based on book values, not market values.

“If you look at the data, because capital ratios are only calculated every quarter and can be manipulated (unlike market values of leverage) none of the capital ratio triggers would have gone off during the recent crisis. This of course defeats the whole purpose of issuing contingent capital. Fortunately, some regulators seem to understand this,” says Vermaelen, who continues to defend his innovation by making presentations across the continent to regulators and bankers.

To read more on this research, click here.

Add a comment Already a member?
We welcome your comments and encourage lively debate. However, to ensure the quality of discussion, our moderators reserve the right not to publish personal attacks, abusive comments or overly promotional content. You can view our Terms & Conditions

Your Privacy

INSEAD takes your privacy very seriously. For this reason, we inform you that the data collected via the form above is processed electronically for the purpose(s) specified in this form and will not be used outside this framework. In accordance with the Data Protection Act of 6 January 1978 amended by the GDPR, you are granted statutory rights of access, modification, update, deletion and limitation of treatment of your personal data. You may exercise these rights at any time by writing or sending an email to INSEAD at insead.knowledge@insead.edu. You have the right, on legitimate grounds, to object to the collection and processing of your personal information. For more information, please see our privacy policy.