It’s no longer about having the link or the hardware or the infrastructure. It’s about what you do with it all
Despite global advances in technological infrastructure, countries without the skills and the regulatory environment to leverage technology are being left behind, according to the 12th Global Information Technology Report (GITR) “Growth and Jobs in a Hyperconnected World”.
The 12th annual report is produced by INSEAD and the World Economic Forum, with sponsorship from Booz & Company. This year, the report shows that developed economies - particularly the Nordic nations and the Asian Tigers of Singapore, Taiwan (China), the Republic of Korea, and Hong Kong SAR - are becoming more adept at finding innovative ways to turn ICT investment into tangible benefits.
The report suggests that when it comes to harnessing ICT investment to improve competitiveness, development, employment and well-being, there is a “profound” and growing gap between Northern and Southern European nations and an even greater disadvantage between advanced and developing economies.
“The digital divide is indeed a very stubborn phenomenon,” Bruno Lanvin, Executive Director of the INSEAD European Competitiveness Initiative (IECI) and the report’s co-editor, told INSEAD Knowledge. “We don’t see it so much in infrastructure and equipment - there the gap is diminishing rather than broadening; emerging countries are investing more and getting more out of their infrastructure. What is increasing is the [divide in countries’] ability to translate ICT into genuine content into something that makes sense for businesses, especially the small and medium-sized enterprises which are prevalent in emerging countries and which enables them to create jobs and improve their standard of living.”
For the first time, Finland has ranked at the top of the GITR’s Networked Readiness Index (NRI) which assesses 144 countries based on their:
- ICT infrastructure; cost of access and the presence of skills to ensure optimal use
- Business’ and government’s efforts to increase the use of ICT
- Business and innovation environment, including the political and regulatory network
- Broader economic and social impacts accruing from ICT
Singapore remained 2nd overall followed by Sweden (3rd) and Netherlands (4th).
The remaining top 10 places went (in order) to Norway, Switzerland, the United Kingdom, Denmark, the United States and Taiwan (China).
Brazil, China, India and Russia (the BRIC nations) which in recent years have been charging ahead in their ability to translate ICT into economic and social impact appear to have hit a wall, stagnating at around the number 50 mark, notes Lanvin suggesting there is a magic “threshold” beyond which return on investment increases significantly. “This analysis shows matching investment in ICT with investment in skills and innovation can help economies cross this threshold.”
Coming in number nine, the United States received its worst ranking since the GITR’s first release in 2001 index when it topped the list. Report authors note this fall is not a sign the nation is losing its innovative capacity - the country still retains the strengths which contributed to making it the world’s innovation powerhouse for decades – but reflects a change in the index methodology and composition as well as the rapid advances made by other economies.
Also noticeable is the deep divide that exists within regions. Foremost is Asia, home to some of the most digitised and innovative economies and the least connected. Unlike Europe, in Asia governments typically lead the digital effort.
European investment crucial
The gap that exists in Europe, between the most advanced Nordic nations and the Southern and Eastern countries, is “alarming” despite the many efforts to create an internal digital market and improve the digital connectivity of converging countries. Low investment in telecommunications is putting at risk not only future consumer benefits but also the region’s overall competitiveness, McKinsey & Company noted in their paper Re-establishing the European Union’s Competitiveness with the Next Wave of Investment in Telecommunications, included in the GITR. “Only bolder regulatory reform can release the scale of modernising investment in telecommunications that Europe needs today if it is to re-establish its competitiveness and enable future economic growth and consumer benefits.” Government can create incentives for investment with policies to reduce the number of operators; allow more pricing flexibility; restrict wholesale access and give operators more spectrum in which to operate.
Elsewhere, huge disparities exist in the Middle East where Israel and some GCC countries have sharply improved their performance looking to make ICT a key national industry, while many North Africa and Levantine nations, particularly those undergoing social and political transition have fallen or stagnated. Progress in improving digital connectivity is also slow in Africa and Latin America.
Digitalisation added 6 million jobs and US$193 billion to the global economy in 2011, says Bahjat El-Darwiche, partner at Booz & Company, a sponsor of the report, noting however that positive impacts were not felt across the board.
“[Digitalisation] creates and destroys jobs,” he adds. “Policy-makers wishing to accentuate the positive impact of digitalisation need to understand these different effects if they wish to act as digital market makers in their economies.”
The report’s authors says the GITR can provide policy-makers and companies with a useful tool for designing national strategies for increased networked readiness and for benchmarking their country’s performance.
The Global Information Technology Report uses a combination of data from publicly available sources and the results of the Executive Opinion Survey of more than 15,000 executives conducted by the WEF and partners.
Bruno Lanvin is Executive Director of the INSEAD European Competitiveness Initiative (IECI).