Skip to main content
Why the World Needs Self-Reflective Leaders.jpg

Leadership & Organisations

Why the World Needs Self-Reflective Leaders

Why the World Needs Self-Reflective Leaders

The coronavirus crisis facilitates the rise of autocratic and narcissistic leaders just when we least need them.

When asked what the post-Covid world might look like, French author Michel Houellebecq said, “The same – only worse.” While the quip is funny on the surface, there is indeed reason for all of us to wonder where the world is headed.

In a recent webinar, Manfred Kets de Vries, INSEAD Distinguished Clinical Professor of Leadership Development & Organisational Change, shared his thoughts on what the current crisis means for leaders. Drawing from the teachings of the early Greek philosophers, he said that the inscription on the temple of Apollo in Delphi, “Know thyself”, remains utterly relevant to this day. Indeed, a large part of his life’s work has been to help executives become more self-reflective leaders.

“Most people are strangers to themselves,” he said. A lot of them resort to the manic defence – filling their calendar with a flurry of activities meant to prevent them from having any time to reflect. They are always running, without knowing what they are running for or running to. Also, they feel drained, but they don’t know why. Others, having reached the pinnacle of professional success, fail to find meaning. All too often, excess greed has left them very lonely.

Looking inward

Kets de Vries promotes what he calls the clinical paradigm as a channel of self-reflection for leaders. The paradigm, in technical speak, involves a psychodynamic-systemic orientation to organisational analysis. “Much of what happens is beyond our conscious awareness,” he said. Fantasies, dreams and symbolism are ways to access this kind of self-knowledge and to reveal our blind spots. Another is reflecting on one’s past, which can form a “lens through which we can understand the present and shape the future”.

Unfortunately, there is no magic pill to become a self-reflective leader, he said. It requires a journey and quite a bit of “Sherlock Holmes” detective work. That is why transformational programmes such as the one for MBAs are often organised in modules, to give participants time to process new information, decipher what’s going on in their inner theatre and ultimately change. The same is true for the programme he has been running at INSEAD for many years – the longest-running programme by the same professor – that one of his colleagues once called the “CEO recycling seminar”.

But why is it so necessary to know thyself as a leader? Essentially, the world has reached an unprecedented level of complexity and the pace of change is dizzying. While the Covid-19 crisis is particularly salient, in that it threatens lives and livelihoods, it is but the latest in an unending stream of disruptions. In such a state of affairs, it is critical for leaders to realise that they can’t be good at everything. It is time to do away with the myth of the CEO as hero.

“Leadership is a team sport,” said Kets de Vries. Leaders need to know their strengths so they can best use them. At the same time, they need to humbly recognise their weaknesses so they can build and empower a team that fills those gaps. And to help leaders to assess their strengths and weaknesses, Kets de Vries has even developed a number of diagnostic tools.

The humility that comes with self-awareness is also critical to fighting off the rise of autocratic leaders, the kind that lives in echo chambers of their own making. Kets de Vries reminded the audience that the sirens of hubris are always beckoning. Many leaders can become self-destructive.

Also, as Kets de Vries pointed out, with crises often comes social regression. People suddenly feel more dependent and start looking for messiahs. The most striking examples of this phenomenon can easily be seen in the political realm. But it is also commonly observed in organisations, where there is natural tendency for people to tell their higher-ups what they want to hear. And after a while, leaders “like it”, he said. Truth tellers aren’t wanted. Even in the best of times, this combination of narcissism and sycophantic behaviour has led to the downfall of giants such as Nokia.

What does meaning mean?

The pandemic is an inflection point. To turn it into an opportunity and a force for good, CEOs need to provide meaning to their employees. Meaning, as Kets de Vries explained, is comprised of purpose (“a forward-looking concept”), a sense of belonging (“we are very social animals”), competence (“what are we good at”), control (“people like to have a voice”) and transcendence (“going beyond the self”).

In an INSEAD Knowledge article, Kets de Vries described his vision of the ideal organisation and even coined a term for it: the authentizotic organisation. He defined it as a trust-based organisation where people find meaning in, and are captivated by their work. It is also a place where people feel safe to speak their mind. Today this is as needed as ever, with a Gallup poll showing that 85 percent of the global workforce is disengaged. According to a Gallup blog, such employees “likely come to work wanting to make a difference – but nobody has ever asked them to use their strengths to make the organisation better”.

The litmus test of a great organisation, Kets de Vries says, is: Would you recommend your workplace to friends and family? Sadly, a lot of organisations are fairly toxic and filled with depressive anxiety and paranoia.`

The webinar was also an opportunity for Kets de Vries to reiterate some of the tips he had previously shared in a Knowledge article for leaders in the Covid era:

  • If layoffs are in the cards, don’t hide in your office even though you feel bad. Now is the time to communicate, communicate, communicate.
  • Don’t cut training and development. As the saying goes, don’t let a crisis go to waste. Make the most of this period to develop your employees’ creative thinking. Discover new avenues for growth.
  • Think long-term. Family-controlled companies might do better than publicly listed ones in this crisis because of their longer-term view, especially if they are value-driven.
  • Cost cutting by itself is far too easy a way out. It doesn’t build for the future. What’s more, it has serious implications in terms of corporate culture.

Although the pandemic is a tragedy and many people have died, it’s also an opportunity for the world to rethink its future. The attitude of employees – particularly individuals in leadership positions – determines how an organisation will perform. According to Kets de Vries, good leadership involves a “delicate dance between disposition and position”, i.e. the ability to resist the intoxicating effects of power. It always requires checks and balances. And above all, it needs self-aware and vulnerable leaders who, to paraphrase Napoleon Bonaparte, can be dealers in hope.

In his latest book, Journeys into Coronavirus Land, Manfred Kets de Vries takes us through his ruminations during confinement, widening his explorations into group phenomenon, leadership, organisational dynamics as well as economic and environmental crisis. The central question is, how have each of us responded to this adversity and where will this journey lead us, individually and collectively? Journeys into Coronavirus Land is free to download. A donation to Unicef’s Save Generation Covid campaign is strongly encouraged.

About the author(s)

About the series

INSEAD thought leaders and their collaborators in the practitioner and entrepreneurship communities offer informed perspectives on how to weather the Covid-19 crisis and emerge from it stronger than ever.
View Comments

Anonymous User

10/09/2020, 11.25 pm

It's so weird because for the pandemic has actually forced me to rethink a lot about my life and meaning in my work and personal life. I have always done a lot of self reflection but with the lockdown, it sort of dialled up to 11.
I assumed almost everyone would be feeling the same way..


Per Berggreen

08/08/2020, 09.20 pm

Wonderful piece with so many condensed insights. It is a joy to see the ancient Greek philosophers revived "Gnoti Seaton"/"Know thyself" - the most basic of human endeavors. A resurrection of Protreptics could be upcoming e.g. Aristotle Protrepticus also extensively treated by Danish Leadership Philosopher Ole Fogh Kirkeby (Existential and value-based coaching). The Gallup stats says it all - and hopefully Houellebecq will be proven wrong, perhaps the developments from Davos will stick further than that forum. Conscious capitalism (Raj Sidodia) and real-life examples like CEO Dob Chapman of Barry-Wehmiller gives us ground to hope.
What better way than to end this comment with a quote from Cato's letter no. 41 "The Emperor Galba's Speech to Piso": "Indeed, to deal faithfully with princes, to reason them into their duty, is a mighty task, and with infinite difficulty performed. But easy is the art of cajoling any prince whatsoever, and in doing it the heart has no share. "


Anonymous User

29/07/2020, 04.53 pm

People do not take the time to sit back and to let their imagination roam. That way, I have developed over half a dozen management models, which I have published in my business books.

Leave a Comment
Please log in or sign up to comment.