Skip to main content
Aerial view of port of Antwerp

Strategy

How to Compete by Shaping Your Ecosystem

How to Compete by Shaping Your Ecosystem

Why you probably won’t – and can’t – solve your industry’s biggest problems alone.
Loading the Elevenlabs Text to Speech AudioNative Player...

If running a business is challenging, consider overseeing operations over 13,000 hectares of land, handling millions of tonnes of goods annually. Managing the Port of Antwerp, one of Europe’s most important gateways, is no trivial feat. Located about 80km inland in northern Belgium, it connects global shipping flows to the industrial heartland of Europe through waterways, roads, rail and logistics networks. 

For decades, ports like Antwerp competed primarily on physical advantages: location, terminal capacity, crane productivity, hinterland access and the ability to handle ever-larger vessels. And like many ports, Antwerp’s operations were challenged by growing container volumes and larger ocean vessels, coupled with labour shortages that exacerbated the capacity crunch at terminals. Container barges that move goods inland via canals were facing long delays, reportedly up to several days.

At first glance, this looked like a capacity problem. But my interviews with actors in the port ecosystem for my case study, Developing a Sustainable Ecosystem Community: The Port of Antwerp, revealed that the hardest challenge was not technological or infrastructural; it was organisational.

The port ecosystem

In many ways, the Antwerp Port Authority is both landlord and convener. It provides shared infrastructure, safeguards the port’s long-term attractiveness and keeps the system working – even though its performance is largely determined by the daily decisions of independent actors.

Each actor is driven by different motivations. Terminal operators seeking utilisation and profitability naturally give priority to large deep-sea vessels. Shipping lines want speed, scale and reliable schedules. Barge operators that transport goods inland through waterways need flexibility and economically viable volumes per trip. Not surprisingly, freight forwarders and shippers care about cost and predictability. Beyond the confines of the port, regulators are concerned with customs, safety and environmental compliance, and neighbouring communities hope to benefit from the jobs and growth a busy port brings without the downsides of congestion, pollution and disruption.

Every choice may be rational from each actor’s point of view. Taken together, however, they can result in gridlock. And while the Port Authority can convene and persuade, it cannot order independent firms to cooperate. Antwerp had to learn to coordinate – or watch the system edge towards paralysis.

What orchestration looked like

On 6 July 2017, the Port Authority and representatives of terminal operators, barge operators, shipping companies, shippers, forwarders and Flemish public authorities signed a declaration of intent. Roughly 40 working-group meetings followed, meant to expose conflicting operating realities, facilitate actors to agree on the problem and convert general support into specific commitments.

The resulting measures include centralised barge scheduling and sharing of digital information for better coordination, the consolidation of small freight volumes for improved economic viability, and the commitment to minimum barge handling capacity by terminals. Each measure required certain trade-offs. Competing terminals surrendered some scheduling autonomy to a shared process; barge operators accepted minimum volumes; and public authorities supported smaller operators to cushion the costs.

The results were tangible. In the pilot phase of the proposed consolidation, the number of terminal visits fell by around 40% while the average volume per visit rose by about 25%. The port also introduced dedicated barge berths and fixed time windows. 

The value of orchestration was not forging a once-and-for-all plan, but the ability to bring competitors and public bodies back to the table, adjust according to the needs of the current or future condition and keep the system viable. The process created both a plan and a community. As conditions changed, the community could renegotiate the plan.

From competition to orchestration

The Port of Antwerp’s actions went beyond traditional strategy, which typically focuses on how a single firm can win. Ecosystem strategy goes one level higher: what must the interdependent system do for its members to compete and create value at all?

Competition does not disappear. Terminal operators still compete, shipping lines still bargain hard and barge operators still protect their economics. But without agreed schedules, trusted data, common interfaces and reciprocal commitments, competition can damage the shared conditions every participant depends on to remain economically viable. For the Port Authority, therefore, strategy means more than moving containers efficiently. It means shaping the physical, digital and relational infrastructure that allows the ecosystem to function.

Nor did congestion disappear after Antwerp merged with the Port of Zeebrugge in Bruges. In 2025, berth waiting times reportedly rose to 44 hours amid labour shortages and low Rhine water levels, while changes in shipping alliances and industrial action added further pressure. Covid-19 had already shown how quickly shipping could be disrupted. Drug trafficking is yet another challenge that requires terminals, shipping agents, customs, inland carriers, police and technology providers to act as a system to improve transparency.

The lesson beyond the port

The lesson from Antwerp is not that orchestration makes hard problems easy, nor that it delivers a permanent solution in an ever-changing environment. Its purpose is to build the capacity to adapt before the next shock pushes the system towards a standstill.

Similar challenges exist in AI governance, where technology firms, regulators, users, data providers and infrastructure companies must coordinate across boundaries. Healthcare depends on hospitals, insurers, pharmaceutical companies, technology platforms and governments working together. Electric mobility and the energy transition require manufacturers, utilities, charging networks, investors and policymakers to move in concert. In each setting, no single actor owns the whole problem, but everyone suffers if the system fails.

When hierarchy is absent and interdependence is unavoidable, what’s needed is not another plan or technology, but a community that recognises its shared fate, and can agree on the problem and renegotiate under pressure. Increasingly, the world’s most important managerial problems sit between organisations. Those who can shape the trust, routines and infrastructure that bind an ecosystem together do more than address today’s bottleneck – they give the system a chance to survive tomorrow’s challenges.

Edited by:

Geraldine Ee

About the author(s)

About the research

View Comments
No comments yet.
Leave a Comment
Please log in or sign up to comment.